There's still time for holiday delivery! Order by 2PM EST on 12/23. Exclusions apply

We're all out
of the ordinary™

favorite_border

favorite_border

featured_seasonal_and_gifts

gift findergift finder

Gifts for Mystery Lovers - Puzzling and Literary Items

Unravel the excitement with this collection of gifts for mystery lovers! From secret message pens to detective-themed puzzles, this assortment is sure to keep them on their toes. Perfect for those who love a good whodunit and a dash of intrigue!

Subscription Science Lovers Mystery Box Subscription $135.00 - $255.00
Usually ships within 24 hrs
ships free with
4.8 stars out of 5starstarstarstarstar 5
customers also boughtkeyboard_arrow_right
A Blind Date with A Book $19.00
Usually ships within 24 hrs
ships free with
4.3 stars out of 5starstarstarstarstar_half 6
customers also boughtkeyboard_arrow_right
The Cat Year: A Year Of Kitty Companionship $22.00
Usually ships within 24 hrs
ships free with
not yet ratedstarstarstarstarstar
customers also boughtkeyboard_arrow_right
Reveal the Custom Message Mystery Game $17.00
Usually ships within 24 hrs
ships free with
5 stars out of 5starstarstarstarstar 3
customers also boughtkeyboard_arrow_right
Solve The Case Escape Room $20.00
Usually ships within 24 hrs
ships free with
4.1 stars out of 5starstarstarstarstar_outline 7
customers also boughtkeyboard_arrow_right
Unlock the Whiskey Escape Room $28.00
Usually ships within 24 hrs
ships free with
4.2 stars out of 5starstarstarstarstar_outline 16
customers also boughtkeyboard_arrow_right
Unlock the Beer Escape Room $30.00
Usually ships within 24 hrs
ships free with
2 stars out of 5starstarstar_outlinestar_outlinestar_outline 1
customers also boughtkeyboard_arrow_right
Subscription Victorian Era Detective Trilogy Subscription $100.00
Usually ships within 24 hrs
ships free with
5 stars out of 5starstarstarstarstar 1
customers also boughtkeyboard_arrow_right
Future Bookworm Literary Building Blocks $28.00
Usually ships within 24 hrs
ships free with
not yet ratedstarstarstarstarstar
customers also boughtkeyboard_arrow_right
Experience Trade Secrets Coffee Tasting Class $90.00
Usually ships within 24 hrs
ships free with
4.9 stars out of 5starstarstarstarstar 48
customers also boughtkeyboard_arrow_right
Legends of the National Parks $35.00
ships free with
4.8 stars out of 5starstarstarstarstar 5
customers also boughtkeyboard_arrow_right
How To Speak Cat Cards $10.00
ships free with
4.8 stars out of 5starstarstarstarstar 28
customers also boughtkeyboard_arrow_right
Death for Dinner Horror Movie Cookbook $25.00
ships free with
5 stars out of 5starstarstarstarstar 5
customers also boughtkeyboard_arrow_right
Unlock the Wine Escape Room Game $28.00
ships free with
4.6 stars out of 5starstarstarstarstar_half 14
customers also boughtkeyboard_arrow_right
Phone Jail Escape Room Game $30.00
ships free with
4 stars out of 5starstarstarstarstar_outline 3
customers also boughtkeyboard_arrow_right

Discover unique gifts for mystery lovers that will keep them guessing and engaged for hours. From intriguing puzzles to clever games, find the perfect present for those who love a good mystery.

Looking for more one-of-a-kind gifts? Check out these other options:

Pickleball Tournament Prizes | Attract Bees And Butterflies | Truth Or Dare Game For Couples | Personalized Birthday Newspaper | Ski Themed Gifts