Uncommon Goods | Bagel & Cream Cheese Making Kit | Everything Bagel, Cinnamon Raisin Bagel, How to Make Bagels

This item is no longer available

Bagel & Cream Cheese Making Kit

Bagel & Cream Cheese Making Kit

Shop bestsellers

The superheroes of our collection: they save the day, every time.

5 stars out of 5starstarstarstarstar

My sister (a baker) absolutely loved this gift! It was something diffe…

  • Mia Spider Hamm
  • Emmaus PA

read full review

5 stars out of 5starstarstarstarstar

This product is super fun and easy to use...and tasty! I would definit…

  • Laurie
  • New York, New York

read full review

5 stars out of 5starstarstarstarstar

We have never tried to make bagels ourselves, but have been interested…

  • Danny
  • St Paul, MN

read full review

4.77
4.77 stars out of 5starstarstarstarstar_half
based on 13 reviews
100%
of respondents would
recommend this to a friend
5 stars
11 users rating this 5 stars
4 stars
1 users rating this 4 stars
3 stars
1 users rating this 3 stars
2 stars
0 users rating this 2 stars
1 star
0 users rating this 1 star
  • 5 stars out of 5starstarstarstarstar
  • Mia Spider Hamm
  • done verified reviewer
  • Emmaus PA

Super great gift!

My sister (a baker) absolutely loved this gift! It was something different she's never tried, and with the cream cheese added in to make too it really was a lovely treat all around!

  • 5 stars out of 5starstarstarstarstar
  • Laurie
  • done verified reviewer
  • New York, New York

Amazing gift Person who received it LOVES it. Super creative

This product is super fun and easy to use...and tasty! I would definitely recommend it!

  • 5 stars out of 5starstarstarstarstar
  • Danny
  • done verified reviewer
  • St Paul, MN

Great for beginning bagelers

We have never tried to make bagels ourselves, but have been interested for some time. I think we were a bit intimidated by the process. This kit made it simple and the bagels were delicious. Would definitely recommend to anyone interested in trying to make bagels at home.

  • 5 stars out of 5starstarstarstarstar
  • StacyE
  • Ithaca, NY

Tasted amazing!

You don't need a good processor for this... we did it by hand and it came out great.

  • 5 stars out of 5starstarstarstarstar
  • KD
  • Baltimore

Fun bagel kit!

We had a blast making these delicious bagels and the instructions were super easy to follow.

  • 4 stars out of 5starstarstarstarstar_outline
  • Linda
  • San Francisco

Perfect bagels the first time!

The kit was easy to make and the bagels turned out great. I could not make the cream cheese with ingredients that were easily obtainable so I have not made it yet.

  • 5 stars out of 5starstarstarstarstar
  • Scorpio10
  • New Mexico

YES!

Everything you need comes in the kit. We printed the directions out on line. Pretty straight forward directions.

  • 3 stars out of 5starstarstarstar_outlinestar_outline
  • Lindsey
  • Nashville

Online-only recipe and equipment requirements

We didn't discover we needed a baking mat or a food processor until we opened this kit and visited the website. Since we have a small-ish kitchen, we had neither (we used a handy blender stick for things like food processing pesto). We actually ordered a four cup food processor just for this recipe for nearly 100 dollars only to discover you need a much larger one. I also don't love that the recipe is exclusively online, forcing you to use a screen while baking, so it would be nice if instructions were printed as well. Packaging is appealing and directions are easy to understand.

Response from merchant

We're sure they were delicious! We have mailed instructions to you to make things easier. Enjoy!

  • 5 stars out of 5starstarstarstarstar
  • Gabriela
  • done verified reviewer
  • Brooklyn, NY

We did it!

So, the process was not entirely-stress free. We could only find ultra-pasteurized heavy cream! Were we rolling the bagels right? But you can't argue with results. Sitting down to eat a meal of bagels with a schmear that you made from scratch is amazing. Next time, it'll be easier.

  • 5 stars out of 5starstarstarstarstar
  • Dan the Man
  • done verified buyer
  • done verified reviewer
  • Chicago, IL

Great gift!

This was a great Valentine's Day gift for my partner! We always go get bagels on the weekend, so we had a blast making our own. We even decided to make the whole batch at once and had our neighbors over to help while drinking mimosas. Made for a fun morning :)

  • FL

Hi- how much sodium is in each or in the total package and I can do the math?

Verified reply from Allison

There is 650 mg of sodium in the total package.

  • Washington, DC

Roughly how long does the whole process take? We're making these bagels as a birthday brunch activity and I just want to have an idea of when we need to start!

Verified reply from Beau

You will need about 2 hours for the whole process, at least! Here's the full instructions with times - https://www.uncommongoods.com/pdf/42916-01.pdf

  • DC

What is the expiration date on these kits? I am looking to purchase some for Christmas (which is 6 months away).

Verified reply from Deniqua

This kit will last a minimum of 90 days once it ships. Feel free to purchase this a little closer to Christmas.

  • undisclosed

How many ounces is the malt syrup? I want to give it as a Christmas gift to my brother who would be flying with his gift as a carry-on back home. Would this pass through airport security? Thanks!

Verified reply from Melody

The malt syrup is .5 oz each! You would need to check with your airline and TSA guidelines.

  • Los Angeles, CA

Is there instructions/recipe on remaking the bagels or is this a one time use packet?

Verified reply from Melody

It comes with instructions! However, the kit only provides enough ingredients to make 12 bagels and 1.5 lbs of cream cheese, so you might need to purchase the ingredients at your local supermarket for a second round of bagels.

  • New Jersey

Is there an allergen statement included on the package and if so what does it say?

Verified reply from Nicola

Hello! The Bagel & Cream Cheese Making Kit is made in the same facility as tree nuts, soy, dairy.

Verified reply from Nicola

Hello! The Bagel & Cream Cheese Making Kit is made in the same facility as tree nuts, soy, dairy.

  • Los Angeles, CA

Where are all of the ingredients for this product specifically sourced from?

Verified reply from SIRandal

Greetings! The vendor advises that they cannot disclose this information because it is proprietary information. I hope this info helps.Thanks for shopping with us and Happy Holidays!

Do you have to make all 12 bagels at once or can you make a smaller number? Thanks.

Verified reply from Sue

We wouldn't recommend doing this because the baking mix might not have the right ratios of ingredients if you separate it for a smaller batch.