Paper Gifts for 1st Anniversaries

Celebrate your first year with one-of-a-kind paper gifts that add a personal touch—because standard just won't cut it for your love story!

read more

Whether you're looking for heartfelt keepsakes or playful surprises, our paper-themed gifts are designed to celebrate your unique journey together. Each piece is crafted with care, making it the perfect way to mark this special milestone in a way that’s as memorable as your love story!

Customizable Custom Love Boat Portrait $75.00 - $125.00
ships free with
4.9 stars out of 5starstarstarstarstar 14
customers also boughtkeyboard_arrow_right
Customizable Intersection of Love - Photo Print $75.00 - $175.00
Usually ships within 8 business days
ships free with
4.9 stars out of 5starstarstarstarstar 1605
customers also boughtkeyboard_arrow_right
Birth Month Flower 3D Art $38.00
Usually ships within 24 hrs
ships free with
4.8 stars out of 5starstarstarstarstar 44
customers also boughtkeyboard_arrow_right
Customizable Custom Love is Art Kit $70.00
Usually ships within 8 business days
ships free with
4.8 stars out of 5starstarstarstarstar 92
customers also boughtkeyboard_arrow_right
Customizable Intersection of Love Personalized Jigsaw Puzzle $45.00
ships free with
4.6 stars out of 5starstarstarstarstar_half 12
customers also boughtkeyboard_arrow_right
Experience Your Love Story Mapmaking Class $110.00
Usually ships within 24 hrs
ships free with
4.9 stars out of 5starstarstarstarstar 58
customers also boughtkeyboard_arrow_right
Paint By Numbers Framed Portrait Kit $40.00
Usually ships within 24 hrs
ships free with
not yet ratedstarstarstarstarstar
customers also boughtkeyboard_arrow_right
What I Love About You by Me Book $10.00
Usually ships within 24 hrs
ships free with
4.6 stars out of 5starstarstarstarstar_half 470
customers also boughtkeyboard_arrow_right
The Anniversary Journal $95.00
Usually ships within 24 hrs
ships free with
4.8 stars out of 5starstarstarstarstar 67
customers also boughtkeyboard_arrow_right
Intimacy Card Deck $25.00
Usually ships within 24 hrs
ships free with
4.9 stars out of 5starstarstarstarstar 16
customers also boughtkeyboard_arrow_right
New! Long Term Couples Connection Card Deck $30.00
ships free with
not yet ratedstarstarstarstarstar
customers also boughtkeyboard_arrow_right
Love Notes - A Letter Writing Kit for Couples $17.00
Usually ships within 24 hrs
ships free with
not yet ratedstarstarstarstarstar
customers also boughtkeyboard_arrow_right
Love Is Art Kit $60.00
Usually ships within 24 hrs
ships free with
4.7 stars out of 5starstarstarstarstar_half 97
customers also boughtkeyboard_arrow_right
A Year of Movie Night Dates $42.00
Usually ships within 24 hrs
ships free with
not yet ratedstarstarstarstarstar
customers also boughtkeyboard_arrow_right
Customizable The Personalized Anniversary Journal $130.00
Usually ships within 8 business days
ships free with
4.9 stars out of 5starstarstarstarstar 206
customers also boughtkeyboard_arrow_right